A Radical Proposal for Biking in San Rafael

A radical proposal to promote biking in downtown San Rafael.

San Rafael has written off Second and Third for too long and ignored the benefits reaped from promoting bicycling. To change it, San Rafael should take the radical step of installing a cycle track on Third, reclaiming at least that part of the city for people.  (Click here for an interactive version of the plan.)

Bicycling is a major part of life in San Anselmo and Fairfax. Though both towns have a long way to go before practical cycling is feasible on its main thoroughfares, both are home to the serious Bikers that hang out around downtown and form the heart of Marin’s bicycling culture. Though proximity to open space may play a role, both towns have done what they could to build a biking culture by installing racks, painting sharrows (Class III lanes) and bike lanes (of the Class II variety), and planning for Class I lanes on arterials. San Rafael, in contrast, has reserved its downtown roads for the car, pushing bikes and even pedestrians out of the way to make room for more Ross Valley car commuters.

This is odd for a number of reasons. San Rafael doesn’t have a major population west of downtown, so the Second/Third arterials almost exclusively serve residents outside their jurisdiction. Yet, the population they do serve are those bicycle-mad San Anselmoans and Fairfaxians. Rather than draw on the best habits of Ross Valley, the arterials draw on its worst.

To remedy this, I propose the San Rafael Bikeway, a two-way separated Class I cycle track. Modeled after Washington, DC’s 15th Street cycle track, the bikeway would be 11 feet wide: four feet for westbound cyclists, four feet for eastbound cyclists, and a three foot buffer. Including the complementary Class II bike lanes east of Grand Ave., the Bikeway would run two miles through the whole of downtown San Rafael.

Practically, the Bikeway would be a major boon to San Rafael. Not only would it take some of the pressure off the roads by putting more people on bikes – a much smaller form of transportation – but it would calm traffic along Third and make the sidewalks along Third much more pedestrian-friendly. Bike lanes of the Class I and II varieties calm traffic, meaning they bring down vehicle speeds and road noise and the protection of a bicycle lane makes the sidewalk more inviting. Calmer streets also tend to have more efficient traffic flow, so Level of Service would likely remain the same.

Perhaps most important is that calmer streets are safer streets. Arterials like Second and Third promote higher driving speeds and cause more severe injury crashes. Putting in the Bikeway and calming even Third would make downtown a far safer place than it is today.

Bicyclists also tend to shop more and spend more than drivers. As the Third Street merchants would be the ones with the best exposure, they would have more to gain from the track’s installation than Fourth Street, rebalancing the downtown.

Politically, the Bikeway would be a major pain for the city. The plan envisions that the 47 parking spaces along Third Street would "float" between the Bikeway and the street during off-peak hours, providing protection against traffic. During rush hour, the parking lane would be a traffic lane, ensuring that cars are still easily whisked back to Ross Valley as unimpeded as they are today.

Though the 47 spaces represent less than 4 percent of parking in the area – 975 spaces* are available in the Third Street garages alone – merchants and drivers typically view any parking as sacrosanct. Removing even a single space can lead to legislative gridlock, and displacing 47, even for just a few hours a day, would likely raise a righteous indignation never before seen in San Rafael.  Ross Valley drivers would probably raise a stink about losing a traffic lane during off-peak hours, though Third has more than enough capacity at two lanes in the middle of the day.

To help allay such fears, San Rafael should approach the problem methodically before even announcing the details of the project. Among the unknowns to study: how many Third Street drivers shop on Third; what’s the typical occupancy of those parking spaces; how many cyclists are expected to use the route in 5 years; how much do cyclists spend in downtown San Anselmo vs. drivers; and how many people will use the intersections per hour in 5 years, and what share of those will be riding bikes. The city must be ready to answer its critics from Day One.

There are a few practical design issues as well. The route has a huge number of curb cuts, which diminish the effectiveness of the Class I concept. The hill at Third and E streets is a relatively steep one for a casual bicyclist. The Second Street segment is incredibly complicated – if Third can be narrowed without removing a traffic lane between Ritter and Union, that would make the eastern half of the route much more simple. These problems should not stop us, though.  Fixing them is only a challenge, not an impossibility.

This is a radical plan, not because of the technical challenge, but because it would require San Rafael to be bold in a way it hasn’t been in the past, and to put people before cars in a way it has definitely not. This plan, or something like it, would reshape both the city and Ross Valley and provide an alternative infrastructure to serve Marin’s cyclists.


*I had to estimate the Third & C lot based on the number of spaces on the top deck.  I might add that I have never once seen a car up there, so we're not exactly wanting for a place to park.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Dr. Philly Cheeseteak May 07, 2012 at 08:43 PM
This is a good idea, I am tired of shrieking when riding my bike around this town. I have bugs stuck on my teeth after a wild ride through the streets of San Rafael. Sometimes i resort to driving my bike on the sidewalk which I know isn't cool--my bike and me are large and we scare little old ladies and small children.
Rico May 08, 2012 at 01:35 AM
A gas motor ? How 1980's. I just got a new full suspension mountain bike, and I found a 4000 watt 3 phase AC brushless hub motor. It runs at 72 volts and I will build a 15 amp hour lithium ion polymer battery pack for it. No, it will not be legal to ride on the streets of San Rafael, and will never be seen in the Cal Park tunnel, but perfect for off road use on Mt. Tam and other areas in west Marin. Ride on.
David Edmondson May 08, 2012 at 04:11 PM
Off-topic: I'm throwing a happy hour at San Rafael Joe's this Thursday at 6pm. Come by, mingle, drink good drinks. It'll be good times. Walking distance from the transit center and The Only Bike Rack, though if you must drive there are 945 spaces to choose from on Third and hundreds more on Second, Fourth, and Fifth.
Bill McGee May 09, 2012 at 11:39 PM
Ricardo - ask your friend what route he takes that is faster than the tunnel? Perhaps a helicopter? The only other alternatives are to go over the Bret Harte hill into Greenbrae, over Wolfe Grade, or the 580 frontage road to Sir Francis Drake Blvd past San Quentin. All these alternate routes are significantly longer and slower than using the tunnel. The tunnel is a huge advantage for anyone cycling Novato to Mill Valley. The tunnel lets out at Larkspur Landing and from there is an easy jump on to the path leading to the overpass to Corte Madera or Larkspur.
xiayutian December 01, 2012 at 01:24 AM
called in his book a “healthy debate” http://www.coachfactoryoutletcc.us /Coach Outlet Onlineover troop levels in the country.But the president’s decision to tap Mr. Petraeus to command the war in Afghanistan, http://www.guccibeltsoutletstores.net /Gucci Beltsand later picking him to lead the C.I.A., effectively ended lingering concerns among Obama political advisers that the http://www.coachoutletonlinewo.com /Coach Outlet Storepopular general might challenge his commander in chief during the election.Mr. Petraeus and his wife met http://www.coachfactorystoredo.com /Coach Factory Onlinewhen he was a cadet at West Point; she was the daughter of the academy’s superintendent and a student at Dickinson http://www.coachfactoryoutletpo.com /Coach Factory Outlet OnlineCollegeinPennsylvania.condemnation on Wednesday.“ The Egyptian people, the Egyptian leadership, http://www.coachoutletonlinefc.org /Coach Outlet Onlinethe Egyptian government and all of Egypt is standing with all its


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »