Dentist Leads Latest Green Biz List
Innovative upgrades help Gabriela Garcia-Rojas land county certification; Piatti's, Acqua Hotel and Mill Valley Inn also on the list.
Longtime Mill Valley dentist Gabriela Garcia-Rojas had long considered herself environmentally conscious. But until she attended a recent lecture on greening the dental industry at a fellow dentist's office in San Leandro, she thought her business had no place on a list of green businesses, particularly given her industry's reliance on things like chemicals, X-rays and plastic molds.
"I said to myself, 'I do way more than him," Garcia-Rojas said of the East Bay dentist, who was certified in Alameda County. "I never thought I would never be able to be a green business. But I called the county and, sure enough, we were doing way more than other dentists that have been qualified as green."
Garcia-Rojas' family and cosmetic dental practice, located on Willow Street, was certified as a green business by the Marin County Board of Supervisors this week, along with fellow Mill Valley businesses Piatti's Ristorante, Acqua Hotel and Mill Valley Inn.
While many of the upgrades needed to attain green business certification are well known, from energy efficient lighting to sustainable waste management, the dental industry presents its own challenges.
For instance, Garcia-Rojas installed an amalgam separator that separates the mercury-laden residue from removed old fillings before it goes down the drain. Her office uses porcelain fillings to replace old ones, a more natural looking and less chemically enhanced substitute.
Instead of the traditional method of making plastic molds of teeth for crowns, Garcia-Rojas does so using a Cerec machine, which makes a digital scan of the tooth. The same is true for traditional X-rays, which are also done digitally and avoids the use of X-ray processing chemicals.
County supervisors hailed 21 green businesses in all this week, bringing the number of Marin's certified green businesses to 406. Garcia-Rojas' practice is the second certified green dentist in Marin, and a third, Haney Orthodontics in San Anselmo, was also certified this week.
The Marin green business program, part of a Bay Area regional project now involving 2,200 businesses, agencies and organizations, was launched in 2002 to encourage recycling, energy efficiency, conservation and related opportunities to boost both economic and environmental resources.
The other Marin green businesses certified this week:
Aah Haa! Inc., San Rafael
Blue Skies Janitorial Services, Novato
C2e LLC, Novato
Greenfire Strategies, Novato
Haney Orthodontics, San Anselmo
High Definition Home, San Rafael
Jessie et Laurent, San Rafael
Marin Mac Tech, Novato
Marin Primary & Middle School, Larkspur
My Alibi Clothing, Inverness
MyEco LLC, Greenbrae
Nick & Laura Photography, San Rafael
Noble Builders, Corte Madera
Simmonds & Associates, San Anselmo
Stella's, San Anselmo
Suzanne Halladay Tax Services, San Rafael
Unity in Marin, Novato
Katie D.
8:18 am on Thursday, August 26, 2010
Any dentist who still uses mercury (that is, "silver" fillings that are mostly mercury) at all is far from green - dentists are among the biggest polluters in our communities. So what if a dentist has an amalgam separator? That catches what? A lousy 5% or so of the total amount of mercury dentists buy. With dentists being the second biggest purchasers of mercury in the US and most of that mercury walking out of the dental office in patients' mouths, our environment is in serious trouble. Mercury fillings are the largest source of mercury from household wastes (i.e. toilets) and a growing source of mercury in our air due to cremation (burial is no better - mercury gets into the soil too). Once in the environment, no separator can control it, it converts into even more toxic forms, it contaminates our fish - and no dentist will take responsibility. This is why the Nordic countries have already banned dental mercury. Our communities need to start standing up to polluting dentists too - no one could ever certify them as "green".
Jim Welte
9:49 am on Thursday, August 26, 2010
Hi Katie - you make some excellent points. If the story didn't make it clear, this particular dentist uses the amalgam separator when removing old, antiquated fillings and does not use those mercury-laden fillings herself. But your points about the perils of mercury are well taken.
Katie D.
9:52 am on Friday, August 27, 2010
Hi Jim,
Your story was clear enough about Dr. Garcia-Rojas not using mercury herself, and I commend her for being mercury-free.
But since so many dentists claim to be green while still using mercury I thought someone needed to clarify what it means to be a green dentist in a world plagued by mercury pollution. For instance, in one recent news release, a dentist advertised herself as “eco-friendly”, but not only still uses amalgam – her office building doubles as residential space. There is a high risk that mercury emissions from the dental office (once again, these cannot be controlled by separators, only by source reduction) will contaminate the air in the residential space where young children – the most susceptible to mercury exposure – will be living according to the article.
Too many dentists install a separator and call themselves environmentally-friendly (and too many governments consider this sufficient to protect our environment). Consumers need to understand the full impact of dental mercury on our environment, question the “green” labels, and demand more than a voluntary certification program -- we need an end to this major source of mercury pollution.
Jim Welte
10:20 am on Friday, August 27, 2010
Fantastic point. Thanks for sharing your perspective on this.